
October 2007
Printer-friendly version
New bariatric surgery techniques successful for long-term weight loss with
fewer complications
By Chris Edwards, M.D.
Obesity has become a worldwide epidemic,
affecting well over 25 percent of individuals in industrialized countries.
In the US alone, more than 60 million adults and 9 million adolescents are
overweight or obese [having a Body Mass Index (BMI) of 30 or greater].
Approximately $80 billion are spent annually
to treat obesity and its accompanying comorbid conditions, including but
not limited to: diabetes mellitus type II, hypertension, sleep apnea,
asthma, severe degenerative joint disease, cardiovascular disease,
congestive heart failure, hyperlipidemia, gastroesophageal reflux disease,
non-alcoholic steatohepatitis, lower extremity venous stasis, stress
incontinence, and depression. These comorbidities can and often do become
life-threatening, directly accounting for the increased mortality of the
morbidly obese.
While many explanations for obesity exist,
effective treatment has proven a difficult challenge for the medical
community. Historically many strategies have been employed, to include
diets, behavior modification, exercise programs, and various medications;
unfortunately, these alone have resulted in failure to achieve clinically
significant weight loss and healthy weight maintenance for most. Surgical
treatment for morbid obesity has been the only proven method of achieving
consistent long-term weight loss, comorbidity improvement and/or
resolution, and subsequent mortality reduction.
Surgical treatment for obesity, known as
bariatric surgery, has been available for several decades, though early on
the long-term results were suboptimal. Early operations such as the
jejuno-ileal bypass focused on significant malabsorption.
While producing successful weight loss this
procedure also resulted in unacceptable long-term malnourishment
complications frequently leading to liver failure and death; due to this,
it was eventually abandoned for a purely restrictive operation known as
the vertical-banded gastroplasty (VBG), or “stomach stapling.”
Early success rates with VBG were
favorable, but greater than five year results proved less than
satisfactory,
largely due to late development of problems such as gastric outlet
obstruction or gastro-gastric fistula caused by staple line breakdown and
resulting in weight regain.
Today’s operative strategies have proven more
successful for producing durable long-term weight loss with fewer
complications than techniques formerly utilized. The Roux-en-Y gastric
bypass (RNYGB) has become the “gold standard” bariatric procedure
performed in the United States. This operation combines a restrictive
component with a mild malabsorptive component (see Figure 1). RNYGB
provides excellent long-term results for weight loss (65-70 percent EBW)
and comorbidity resolution.
RNYGB can be performed both laparoscopically and through an open incision;
the trend has shifted strongly toward laparoscopic procedures which are
inherently characterized by fewer complications, shorter hospital stays,
and significantly accelerated recovery periods.
The
laparoscopic adjustable gastric band (Lap-Band), an almost exclusively
laparoscopic procedure that has been performed on over 200,000 patients
worldwide, is the most recent surgical weight loss option gaining momentum
in the US. The Lap-Band provides restriction to the upper stomach by
creating a small gastric “pouch” (see Figure 2). The degree of restriction
can be adjusted with ease postoperatively via percutaneous port access.
This restriction provides optimum satiety with
only a small meal. Although weight loss with Lap-Band is slower as
compared with RNYGB, studies at the four- to five-year mark demonstrate
results that rival RNYGB with regard to both weight loss and comorbidity
resolution. Surgical risks and complications are considerably fewer and
less severe because gastrointestinal anatomy is not disrupted. The
Lap-Band can be placed safely in the outpatient surgery setting for most
patients with minimal time off work.
The sleeve gastrectomy and biliary pancreatic
diversion with duodenal switch (BPD-DS) are two other bariatric operations
currently available; however, they are usually performed at large academic
centers and are typically reserved for the super morbidly obese. Close
follow up is extremely important with the BPD-DS to avoid complications
caused by micronutrient deficiencies.
Locally, the Roux-en-Y gastric bypass and
Lap-Band are options currently available to surgically treat obesity.
These operations, combined with an extensive multidisciplinary program,
have produced excellent results.

Prior to being considered for bariatric
surgery, prospective patients must meet criteria based on recommendations
from the National Institutes of Health. The patient must have a BMI of at
least 35 with at least one comorbidity present or a BMI of 40 or greater
with or without comorbidity to be considered. The patient must have made
multiple previous dietary attempts at weight loss.
Additionally, the patient must complete a
preoperative multidisciplinary preparatory regimen to include evaluation
by a registered dietician, consultation with an exercise physiologist, a
psychological evaluation, and extensive behavioral health education. A
full team of internists and specialists are available for those patients
who require additional medical clearance and/or preparation to optimize
the patient’s health status prior to surgery; this may include a required
weight loss to assist with the laparoscopic approach.
For all patients, a two-week liquid diet regimen is required prior to
surgery which shrinks the liver volume, making it more pliable and more
easily retracted, resulting in safer and improved access to the esophageal
hiatus.
Follow up is an essential part of bariatric
surgery. RNYGB requires periodic follow up with micronutrient laboratory
testing at least annually to assure that the patient remains metabolically
sound. Calcium citrate, vitamin B12, and multivitamin supplements are
necessary lifelong postoperatively due to the degree of malabsorption
resulting from RNYGB. Reductions in medications will likely be needed as
comorbidities improve or resolve as a result of weight loss.
Dietary changes are also required. High protein, low carbohydrate
(sugar-free), and low fat are the mainstay. The first six months the
patient takes in approximately 600 cal/day, then gradually increases to
about 1,000-1,200 cal/day for lifelong maintenance.
For Lap-Band patients, periodic adjustments
are needed to ensure appropriate satiety and portion control. The first
adjustment is made about 6 weeks after placement. Additional adjustments
are needed when satiety increases and weight loss plateaus. Most Lap-Band
adjustments are performed under fluoroscopic guidance; however,
adjustments may also be performed in the bariatric surgeon’s office
without fluoroscopy.
If weight loss slows and the Lap-Band patient
can eat more easily without feeling restriction, an adjustment is likely
needed. As with RNYGB, dietary and behavioral/lifestyle changes must be
made to make surgery successful.
While it is the only proven modality to
significantly affect obesity and comorbid conditions, surgery is only one
tool in the weight loss arsenal. As resources become more limited and
health care costs further escalate, our focus must be prevention of
obesity and maintenance of a healthy weight – and education must be at the
forefront of the attack. It is imperative that appropriate diet and
exercise habits are instilled at an early age.
Our children are suffering from obesity at increasingly alarming
proportions, and their life expectancies are becoming less than their
parents’ as the incidence of obesity continues to skyrocket. Even with
aggressive medical and educational intervention, positive changes may take
several generations to fully realize. Until then, surgical intervention
is and likely will remain the most effective treatment for the disease of
morbid obesity.
If you have patients
with qualifying co-morbidities present, who exhibit a desire & strong
determination to lose weight, and who would benefit from either
traditional bypass or banding procedures, please call Physician Referral
at 800-909-8326. You may also direct your patient to
http://www.stjohns.com/services/weightmanagement.aspx
or have them call St. John’s Clinic-General & Specialty Surgery at
417-820-3800 and ask for the bariatric coordinator.
|